Discovering the Best Times Square Pizzerias: A Local’s Guide to NYC’s Pizza Scene
New York City is renowned for its vibrant culture, iconic landmarks, and, of course, its delicious pizza. Among the many culinary experiences, few can rival the joy of indulging in a hot, cheesy slice right in the bustling heart of Times Square. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or an experienced traveler, navigating the myriad of pizza shops can be a challenge. Not all pizza joints are created equal, especially in such a tourist-heavy area. That’s why I’ve compiled this list of top-notch pizzerias near Times Square that guarantee unforgettable flavors and memorable experiences.
Joe’s Pizza Broadway: A Slice of Tradition
A staple within the NYC pizza landscape, Joe’s Pizza has been satisfying cravings since 1975. Established by Joe Pozzuoli, a true pizza aficionado from Naples, Italy, the Broadway location serves the classic New York-style slice. Picture a perfectly made thin crust, golden brown, topped with layers of gooey mozzarella and rich tomato sauce.
This pizza haven is easily recognizable by the walls adorned with photos of celebrities like Leonardo DiCaprio and Jennifer Lopez who flock here for a slice. There’s no dine-in experience here; you can either eat at the counter or snag one of the small tables. Do yourself a favor and try the classic cheese or a Sicilian slice to understand why Joe’s has become a city legend.
Contact: joespizzaofnewyork.com
Phone: (646) 559-4878
Address: 1435 Broadway, New York, NY 10018
Capizzi: Wood-Fired Wonders
Just a short stroll from Times Square leads you to Capizzi, a family-run pizzeria embedded in the vibrant Hell’s Kitchen district. What sets Capizzi apart is its dedication to wood-fired pizza, producing thin-crust personal pies that boast an irresistible combination of flavors.
The menu allows for plenty of customization with upscale toppings like Prosciutto di Parma and caramelized fennel. Signature dishes worth trying are the Asparagus Special infused with truffle oil and the Uovo, adorned with fresh eggs and sautéed onions. If you have room after your pizza, don’t skip out on their delectable desserts like the Nutella pizza or Oreo truffle cannoli.
Contact: capizzinyc.com
Phone: (646) 476-5120
Address: 547 9th Ave, New York, NY 10018
Emmy Squared: Detroit-Style Delight
Emmy Squared, an establishment originally from Williamsburg, offers a refreshing twist to the classic New York pizza experience. Known for its delicious Detroit-style pizza, the crust is thick, fluffy, and perfectly remastered.
Here, your slice is an experience! Engage your palate with flavors from the Classic red sauce topped with mozzarella to the innovative MVP layered with both red and vodka sauces. Dining at Emmy Squared is comfortable, as the pizzas are served hot on cooling racks, inviting you to savor every bite.
Contact: emmysquaredpizza.com
Phone: (929) 484-3669
Address: 311 W 48th St, New York, NY 10036
Artichoke Basille’s Pizza: A Unique Twist
Founded in the East Village and now with a location near Times Square, Artichoke Basille’s introduced their famous artichoke slice, which is a creamy delight featuring artichoke hearts, mozzarella, and spinach drizzled with a savory cream sauce.
Diners can grab a table in the inviting ambiance or take their slice to-go. Beyond the artichoke pizza, the crab pizza offers a sumptuous twist that you won’t want to miss. This place is perfect for experiencing New York’s versatile pizza culture.
Contact: artichokepizza.com
Phone: (212) 600-8635
Address: 1410 Broadway, New York, NY 10018
Upside Pizza: Artistry in Every Slice
If you’re looking for a slice that stands out in both taste and presentation, head to Upside Pizza. Established in 2019, this spot features artisanal pizzas made with house-made ingredients. The sourdough starter in their crust elevates the traditional New York-style pizza into something special.
Enjoy unique combinations, like the Mushroom WWLC, which showcases the culinary flair unique to Upside. Their garlic knots, featuring a buttery crust, cannot be overlooked. Casual dining awaits in this funky, modern space perfect for grabbing a quick bite while enjoying the local atmosphere.
Contact: upsidepizza.com
Phone: (646) 484-5244
Address: 598 8th Ave, New York, NY 10018
The Pizza Experience Awaits
Exploring the vibrant world of pizza near Times Square is a must for any visitor to New York City. Each pizzeria offers its own distinctive take on this classic dish, ensuring there’s something to cater to every palate. The excitement of biting into a freshly made slice—whether it’s a traditional New York-style, a vegetarian delight, or a specialty masterpiece—captures the essence of dining in NYC. With these top locations in mind, your journey through the city’s pizza scene will be a delicious adventure to remember!
