The Best Pizza Slices in New York City
New York City is known for many things, but one culinary staple stands out above the rest: pizza. The city’s vibrant landscape is dotted with countless pizza joints, each offering its unique take on this beloved dish. From classic cheese slices to innovative specialty pies, the choices can be overwhelming. Whether you’re a lifelong resident or a tourist exploring the Big Apple, a slice of pizza is a must-try. Here’s a rundown of some top spots that deliver unforgettable pizza experiences across Manhattan.
Iconic Slice Shops You Can’t Miss
New York’s allure lies in its rich history, and its pizza culture is no exception. Many pizzerias have become institutions, each with a distinct story to tell.
Joe’s Pizza
Located in Greenwich Village, Joe’s Pizza has been serving up classic New York-style slices since 1975. Founded by Naples native Joe Pozzuoli, the pizzeria is known for its no-frills but delicious offerings. The pepperoni and plain cheese slices claim the spotlight here, with crispy edges that cradle gooey melted mozzarella. If you find yourself in the neighborhood, stopping by Joe’s — with lines often moving fast, you can grab a slice without losing much time.
Website: joespizzanyc.com
Location: Multiple locations in Manhattan
Prince Street Pizza
In the trendy Nolita neighborhood, Prince Street Pizza is hard to miss. Famous for its Sicilian square slices, especially the Spicy Spring pie, this pizzeria has quickly become a favorite since its opening in 2012. The thick crust, combined with spicy pepperoni cups and a rich tomato sauce, makes each slice irresistibly good. Their menu also includes classic options like fresh mozzarella and basil for those who prefer traditional flavors.
Website: princestreetpizza.com
Address: 27 Prince Street, New York, NY 10012
New Takes on Classic Flavors
While traditional pizza is cherished, many eateries offer unique interpretations that challenge the status quo.
Mama’s TOO!
Located in the Upper West Side and West Village, Mama’s TOO! has built a reputation for its creative flavor combinations. Their Angry Nonna, adorned with hot soppressata and honey, brings a beautiful balance of spicy and sweet, while the Cacio e Pepe Pizza channels the classic pasta dish using a rich, cheesy base. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make it an excellent place to enjoy an inventive slice.
Website: mamastoo.com
Location: Multiple locations in Manhattan
L’Industrie Pizzeria
This Williamsburg gem is known for using high-quality ingredients and crafting delicious pizzas that pay homage to tradition while pushing boundaries. L’Industrie has expanded to a new West Village location, continuing to serve classics like margherita alongside specialty options such as a Burrata Slice. Both the taste and the thoughtfully designed sandwiches keep patrons coming back for more.
Website: lindustriebk.com
Address: 104 Christopher Street, New York, NY 10014
Neighborhood Favorites
In NYC, you can find beloved local pizzerias that embody the spirit of their neighborhoods.
Scarr’s Pizza
On Orchard Street, Scarr’s Pizza provides a nod to nostalgia with its 1970s vibe and locally sourced ingredients. The pizzeria stands out with homemade flour, resulting in a chewy and well-seasoned crust. Diners can enjoy classic pies or venture into vegetarian options, all made with love and precision.
Website: scarrspizza.com
Address: 35 Orchard Street, New York, NY 10002
Upside Pizza
Founded by pizza aficionados with extensive experience in the slice game, Upside Pizza combines quality ingredients with innovative techniques. The Mozzarella is crafted from scratch, and their specialty pies, like the Mushroom WWLC with white wine lemon cream, are great for those looking to try something different yet delicious.
Website: upsidepizza.com
Location: Multiple locations in Manhattan
Why Pizza Matters in NYC
Pizza isn’t just food in New York City; it’s a cultural phenomenon. It brings people together, serves as a quick bite amid the hustle, and exists as a culinary art form. Each slice offers a taste of the city’s diversity and creativity. So, as you traverse the crowded streets of Manhattan, make sure to indulge in the numerous slice options, from beloved classics to inventive newcomers. There’s a pizza waiting to be discovered just around the corner, promising an explosion of flavors with every bite. Whether it’s late-night cravings or midday munchies, New York’s pizza scene has a slice for everyone.
