Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

News

Every Pizza Style Ranked: From Worst to Best

Get ready to discover the surprising rankings of pizza styles, from the least loved to the ultimate favorite, and find out which one reigns supreme!

pizza style ranking breakdown

Ranking pizza styles involves evaluating their distinct characteristics, origins, and flavors. Starting from the least favored, Altoona-Style pizza features a thick crust with American cheese. Next is St. Louis-Style, known for its cracker-like base and Provel cheese. Pizzaz, from South Philadelphia, uniquely omits sauce, relying solely on quality American cheese. Colorado-Style offers a honey-infused crust balancing chewiness with gourmet toppings. As we climb the ranks, Philadelphia Tomato Pie impresses with its rich umami flavor, while Chicago-Style Deep-Dish is recognized for its buttery crust and layers of cheese. New York and Neapolitan styles culminate in a celebrated pizza experience; further exploration reveals even more insights.

Altoona-Style Pizza

Altoona-style pizza originates from Altoona, Pennsylvania. This variant features a thick Sicilian-style crust topped generously with American cheese, creating a hearty taste that sets it apart from other types. The substantial, doughy base offers a satisfying chewiness, making it a favorite for those who enjoy a robust pizza experience.

In the realm of pizza rankings, Altoona-style pizza often receives praise for its unique characteristics. Its rich, cheesy topping is paired with savory sauce, typically layered on top of the cheese. This technique enhances flavor and provides a delightful texture.

While traditional options like Neapolitan or New York-style pizzas are often favored, Altoona-style pizza maintains its own distinct presence. Its unique features attract those in search of comfort food that allows for culinary exploration. In the quest for the ultimate pizza experience, Altoona-style pizza emerges as a hearty choice, highlighting the diverse possibilities within pizza creations.

St. Louis-Style Pizza

St. Louis-style pizza features a thin, cracker-like crust and the unique Provel cheese blend, which includes cheddar, Swiss, and provolone. This combination creates a distinctive flavor that sets it apart from other types of pizza. The crust is rolled out to an ultra-thin consistency and baked until it reaches a crisp texture.

Provel cheese melts beautifully, offering a creamy, buttery taste that defines this pizza. Instead of traditional triangular slices, St. Louis pizza is cut into squares or rectangles, making it easy to share and enjoy in bite-sized pieces. Toppings can vary widely, with local favorites like pepperoni, sausage, and a variety of vegetables.

St. Louis pizza embodies a spirit of culinary adventure, appealing to those seeking something different from the more widely known Chicago or New York pizzas. While it may not have the same national recognition, St. Louis-style pizza proudly showcases its regional identity, inviting pizza lovers to explore its innovative flavors.

Pizzaz

creative recipe for pizza

St. Louis-style pizza features Provel cheese and a thin crust. Pizzaz, rooted in South Philadelphia, offers a twist by omitting sauce and using American cheese generously. This approach focuses on simple flavors, allowing the cheese to shine. Unlike traditional pizzas laden with marinara, Pizzaz highlights the boldness of American cheese, which melts to create a creamy texture that pairs perfectly with the crispy crust.

The lack of sauce does not mean a lack of flavor; it opens the door for creativity. Many fans enhance their Pizzaz with toppings such as pepperoni, mushrooms, or a drizzle of olive oil, adding a personal flair. The thin, crispy crust provides a solid base for the rich cheese and toppings, ensuring each bite is delightful.

In a world of various pizza options, Pizzaz distinguishes itself with its straightforward philosophy and commitment to quality ingredients. This combination appeals to those who enjoy a pizza that embraces simplicity while delivering a satisfying, cheesy experience.

Colorado-Style Pizza

Colorado-style pizza features a honey-infused crust, which brings a unique sweetness to the pie and pairs well with a wide array of toppings. This pizza has a medium-thick base that strikes a perfect balance between chewiness and crispness, appealing to those who enjoy a substantial bite. The honey enhances the flavor and gives the crust a delightful golden-brown finish, enticing diners to indulge.

Toppings on Colorado-style pizza are plentiful and varied, often showcasing local produce and creative culinary expressions. Popular selections include an assortment of meats, seasonal vegetables, and gourmet cheeses, allowing for a customized pizza experience. This style invites culinary exploration, attracting adventurous food lovers eager to try new flavor combinations.

Beyond its unique taste and texture, Colorado-style pizza fosters a sense of community. Numerous pizzerias in Colorado create a friendly atmosphere where guests can come together to celebrate their passion for this distinctive dish. Ultimately, Colorado-style pizza is distinguished not only by its flavor but also by the spirit of creativity it inspires, encouraging individuals to personalize their experience and savor a slice of innovation.

New England-Style Greek Pizza

pizza with feta cheese

New England-style Greek pizza is characterized by its unique olive oil crust, which provides a distinct flavor and texture that sets it apart from other styles. This pizza often features multiple cheese variations, allowing for a rich and savory taste profile that appeals to a wide range of palates. Typically served in a circular format, it presents a visually appealing option that can be easily shared among diners, enhancing the communal aspect of the dining experience.

Unique Olive Oil Crust

The unique olive oil crust of New England-style Greek pizza features a rich flavor and moisture, creating a distinctive base for the array of cheeses that typically top this regional favorite. This crust is notable for its preparation method, which involves a generous layer of extra virgin olive oil, enhancing both taste and chewiness—a quality cherished by pizza aficionados.

In New England, this olive oil crust is baked in a cast-iron pan, leading to crispy edges while keeping the center soft. This technique results in a crust that is satisfying to bite into yet flexible enough for various toppings. The use of high-quality olive oil reflects Mediterranean culinary influences, offering a healthier option compared to traditional fats.

Additionally, the olive oil crust acts as a foundation for the bold flavors that characterize New England-style Greek pizza. By balancing richness and moisture, it elevates the overall dining experience, encouraging pizza enthusiasts to relish every bite. This delightful combination of texture and flavor establishes the olive oil crust as a defining element in the realm of pizza.

Multiple Cheese Variations

Cheese variations significantly shape New England-style Greek pizza, enhancing its flavor and texture. This pizza typically features a blend of cheeses, prominently mozzarella and feta. Mozzarella offers a creamy, stretchy consistency, while feta adds a salty, crumbly taste, creating a delightful balance.

Some pizzerias, such as Santarpio's or Pizzeria Regina, experiment with additional cheeses like provolone or ricotta. This variety enriches the flavor profile and allows customization, appealing to different taste preferences.

The cheeses meld perfectly with the pizza's signature olive oil crust, contributing a layer of richness that elevates the overall taste. This emphasis on diverse cheese combinations is a hallmark of New England-style Greek pizza, distinguishing it from other regional varieties and providing a unique culinary adventure that celebrates creativity and individual tastes.

Circular Serving Style

New England-style Greek pizza stands out with its circular serving format, creating an inviting and shareable experience that enhances mealtime enjoyment. This pizza variety features a distinctive olive oil-infused crust, achieving a perfect balance of crispiness and tenderness, which serves as an ideal base for a myriad of toppings. The round shape not only enhances visual appeal but also encourages a communal atmosphere, making it easy for friends and family to share slices.

Typically adorned with a combination of cheeses such as feta and mozzarella, this pizza offers a rich blend of flavors. Common toppings include fresh vegetables, assorted meats, and aromatic herbs, resulting in a well-rounded taste that caters to diverse preferences. The circular presentation encourages diners to savor each slice, allowing for personal choice while promoting a laid-back environment.

Beyond its deliciousness, the circular format of New England-style Greek pizza embodies a friendly dining culture, where sharing is both encouraged and celebrated. This characteristic makes it a beloved option for gatherings and a highlight at any meal. Ultimately, this pizza captures the essence of culinary freedom and communal enjoyment.

Philadelphia Tomato Pie

Philadelphia Tomato Pie stands out with its unique flavor profile, characterized by a focaccia-like crust and a rich, umami-packed topping of caramelized tomatoes and anchovies. This style of pizza reflects traditional preparation methods that have been passed down through generations, emphasizing a simple yet robust approach to ingredients. As we investigate its distinct qualities, we can appreciate how this regional specialty contributes to the broader landscape of pizza styles.

Unique Flavor Profile

One of the standout features of Philadelphia's tomato pie is its umami-rich taste, achieved through the generous use of high-quality anchovies and a caramelized tomato topping that enhances its savory character. This distinctive combination creates a pizza that is both flavorful and unique, distinguishing it from traditional styles. The artisanal anchovies add a depth and richness that blends beautifully with the sweetness of the caramelized tomatoes.

Moreover, the crust of the Philadelphia tomato pie is not just a foundation but an essential part of the flavor experience. Its focaccia-like consistency, with a slightly chewy interior and crispy exterior, complements the toppings without overshadowing them. The harmony of flavors is thoughtfully crafted, making each bite an intricate interplay of salty, sweet, and savory sensations.

Furthermore, the use of premium ingredients, such as fresh Roma tomatoes and hand-packed anchovies, elevates the dish to gourmet status. This attention to detail in flavor composition appeals to those seeking a pizza that deviates from the ordinary. In summary, Philadelphia's tomato pie offers an exciting culinary adventure, encouraging pizza enthusiasts to discover a unique flavor profile that is both gratifying and unforgettable.

Traditional Preparation Methods

When creating a classic Philadelphia tomato pie, the process starts with a meticulously crafted dough that achieves a focaccia-like consistency, ensuring a delightful blend of chewiness and crispiness. This pizza variation is known for its distinctive layering of flavors and textures, making it an exceptional option for culinary enthusiasts seeking diverse experiences.

The traditional preparation consists of several essential steps:

  1. Dough Creation: The dough undergoes a slow fermentation process, enhancing its flavor and resulting in an airy structure.
  2. Tomato Foundation: Ripe, crushed tomatoes are generously spread across the dough, often enhanced with anchovies to provide a rich umami flavor.
  3. Cheese Application: A generous layer of mozzarella cheese is added, sometimes mixed with grated Romano cheese for an extra layer of complexity.
  4. Baking Process: The pie is baked at high temperatures, allowing the crust to achieve a satisfying crispness while the toppings harmonize perfectly.

The outcome is a pizza that is not only flavorful but also a homage to traditional culinary craftsmanship, inviting pizza aficionados to savor a slice of history. This method celebrates the art of Philadelphia's food heritage, highlighting the creativity that stems from mastering straightforward yet impactful cooking techniques.

Chicago-Style Deep-Dish Pizza

thick crust cheesy delight

Chicago-style deep-dish pizza features a thick, buttery crust that acts as a robust base for layers of mozzarella cheese, various toppings, and a rich tomato sauce. This unique pizza variety originated in Chicago during the 1940s, crafted by chefs aiming to redefine traditional pizza. The crust is typically formed in a round, deep pan, allowing for an ample filling that distinguishes it from other pizza types.

The standard assembly of a deep-dish pizza begins with a layer of mozzarella cheese directly on the crust. Following this, toppings such as Italian sausage, bell peppers, or pepperoni are added, culminating with a hearty tomato sauce that blankets the ingredients, shielding them from the oven's heat. The outcome is a substantial dish that is commonly enjoyed with utensils.

Though some purists may contend that it diverges too much from classic pizza, deep-dish pizza has garnered a devoted fanbase, appealing to those who appreciate a filling and hearty meal. For many, Chicago-style deep-dish pizza represents more than just food; it embodies the essence of culinary creativity.

New York-Style Pizza

New York-style pizza boasts large, foldable slices, a thin yet sturdy crust, and a balanced ratio of mozzarella to toppings, symbolizing the vibrant food scene of New York City. This classic pizza has garnered a loyal fan base thanks to its convenience and diverse topping options. Here are four defining characteristics of New York-style pizza:

  1. Crust: The base is thin but provides a satisfying chew, serving as the perfect foundation for a variety of toppings.
  2. Cheese: Typically topped with generous amounts of mozzarella cheese, it melts beautifully, creating a deliciously gooey texture.
  3. Toppings: While traditional choices like pepperoni and sausage are popular, the ability to customize with numerous toppings enhances its appeal.
  4. Slice Size: The large, foldable slices make it ideal for quick consumption, reflecting the fast-paced lifestyle of New Yorkers.

The evolution of New York-style pizza reflects the city's cultural diversity, encouraging creativity while honoring its classic roots. This combination of convenience and flavor solidifies its status as a beloved icon in the culinary landscape.

Neapolitan Pizza

thin crust fresh ingredients

Neapolitan pizza is celebrated for its simplicity and authenticity. This traditional dish features a thin crust, wood-fired to achieve perfection, allowing fresh ingredients to shine. Originating from Naples, Italy, this pizza typically includes San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella di bufala, fresh basil, and a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil.

The dough is made from high-quality Caputo flour, water, salt, and yeast, hand-stretched to retain an airy, soft texture. Cooking in a wood-fired oven at high temperatures creates a distinctive char and slight crunch on the crust, enhancing flavor and preserving the moisture of the toppings.

Neapolitan pizza is known for its balance. The acidity of the tomatoes complements the creaminess of the mozzarella, while the basil adds a burst of freshness. This style embodies the Italian philosophy of 'less is more,' demonstrating how quality ingredients can produce a culinary masterpiece. For pizza lovers seeking a refined experience, Neapolitan pizza represents a dedication to tradition and craftsmanship.

Written By

Luca Santoro is a seasoned food writer with 16 years in the hospitality industry across eight countries. His expertise spans craft beer, spirits, and pizza making, all while championing sustainability. A graduate of Collingwood College, Luca combines curiosity and analytical thinking to inspire others, exploring culinary trends through hands-on learning and engaging storytelling.

You May Also Like

Pizza Recipes

New York-style pizza holds a special place in the hearts and stomachs of pizza lovers worldwide. With its thin, foldable slices and delectable combination...

Pizza Ovens

Pizza is one of my favorite foods; there’s nothing better than a perfectly cooked pizza straight from a pizza oven. However, achieving that perfect...

Pizza Recipes

St. Louis-style pizza has captured pizza lovers’ hearts and taste buds with its unique characteristics and flavors. This distinct pizza style, popular in the...

Pizza Recipes

Chicago-style pizza is a beloved culinary tradition that originated in Windy City. Its deep-dish crust, generous toppings, and special assembly order make it a...